Roderick Buchanan: Understanding versus Sympathy
Video portrait of the Irish historian Owen Dudley Edwards
This article is from 2016.
The words 'In Memorium' may be carved above the entrance to the chapel in the Edinburgh Cowgate church once at the centre of the capital's 'Little Ireland', but Roderick Buchanan's new film installation is anything but an elegy. As the film's subject, Irish-born but Edinburgh-based historian Owen Dudley Edwards, talks about James Connolly, the Cowgate-sired radical who rose to fame through his role in the 1916 Easter Rising in Dublin, an entire history is rolled back and has fresh life breathed into it.
Over almost two hours of close-up conversation broken up by Brechtian-style captions, Dudley Edwards talks about church, state, politics and power in Ireland, Scotland and the bridges between the two. There are thumbnail portraits of Edinburgh and Dublin's psycho-geography past and present and a nod too to Connolly's great-grandnephew, journalist Ian Bell, who sadly died in December 2015.
Each answer a now seventy-something Dudley Edwards gives to interviewer Johnny Rogers is a gloriously discursive monologue that twinkles with anecdotal flourishes. His points are made with razor-sharp insight in this essential study of history-makers past and present.
St Patrick's Church, Cowgate until 28 Aug, free.