Edinburgh Festival Guide

Reviews & features: Suzanne Black

Sorted by date / title / rating.

The Wake

23 Aug 20103 stars

A nifty, audience-aware caper

Recreating his father’s wake, impressionist David does his whole family, his wife does them differently, and they both do each other in a bid to find out who ‘did’ Alison. Jonathan Brittain’s award-winning student comedy is a nifty, audience-aware caper…

Paul Sweeney and Tom Webb

23 Aug 20103 stars

An hour of average comedy with a respectable laugh ratio

Tom Webb is 5’5’’ of nervous energy, has four insightful handy hints, two self-effacing stories and one audience survey. Paul Sweeney has one full moustache, four slight comedy songs, lots of good ad-libbing and some lovely tattoos. It adds up to an…

Susan Calman

23 Aug 20103 stars

A vitriolic manual in self-loathing

Glasgow’s pint-sized, squeaky-voiced professional lesbian talks us through her obituary. Written when she was drunk, it’s a vitriolic manual in self-loathing. Calman deftly manages the tricky task of stuffing truth into a comedy-shaped bag tied up with…

Mark Allen

23 Aug 20103 stars

Confident delivery often resulting in pleasing set-ups

In our time-starved, online lives, Mark Allen investigates savouring rather than saving time over 90 languorous minutes. The concept, although not earth-shattering, is admirably adhered to with Allen’s confident delivery often resulting in pleasing…

Tom Allen

20 Aug 20103 stars

Navigating social dilemmas with confidence

People often think their witty pub pal could be a stand-up. They’re often wrong. It takes effort to pull off the role of gay BFF gossiping about recent dramas but Allen succeeds. His show about navigating social dilemmas with confidence is well-crafted…

back to top

The Lasses, O

19 Aug 20103 stars

Scots narrative by the Scottish Bard’s women

Janet Paisley re-animates a spectre from the hearts and minds of all those who were raised in Scotland or study its literary history, Robert Burns. Through the testimonies of five women close to him (midwife, storyteller, mother-in-law, smuggler and…

No Child ...

18 Aug 20104 stars

One-woman performance schools the school system

Actress Nilaja Sun plays actress and drama teacher Miss Sun and her class of students as they put on the play Our Country’s Good, which is about convicts putting on a play. The logistics of one woman flitting from grizzled custodian to idealistic…

Atrium

17 Aug 20103 stars

Theatre interrupted

Last year Belt Up caused a stir by blindfolding the audience during The Trial. Even without blindfolds there is a great deal of trust placed in a theatre company: to guide the audience clearly (and safely) to an as-yet unknown destination. When standard…

Creatures

16 Aug 20104 stars

The humour is toe-curlingly awkward

Susan Harrison is a tiny wee ball of ginger energy. Her character sketch show is akin to being at a conference in The Office with the cast of Animaniacs: the humour is toe-curlingly awkward and the characters like twisted fairy tales. It’s better than…

Bang Bang You’re Dead

13 Aug 20102 stars

Update to 1999 version lacks emotional force of original

Writer William Mastrosimone and director Michael Fisher update their 1999 attempt to make sense of student Kip Kinkel’s killing spree at Thurston High School, Springfield, Oregon. This well-respected version lacks the emotional force attributed to the…

back to top

Imperial Fizz

12 Aug 20104 stars

Fast-talking 1930s drawing room satire with a twist

Like the spirit of Oscar Wilde (all barbed wit and intricate language) filtered through a dark Lovecraftian sensibility, Imperial Fizz adds an extra ingredient to a classic recipe to delicious effect. Sophie Fletcher directs American Brian Parks…

Decky Does A Bronco

12 Aug 20104 stars

Winning revival of site-specific coming-of-age drama

Reviving its award-winning 2000 production of Douglas Maxwell’s site-specific play Grid Iron set up home in a Canonmills park. In a circular arena focused on a swingset David, a self-confessed ‘pathological reminiscer’, dredges up childhood…

The White Dalmatian

12 Aug 20103 stars

Fairytale musical with a twist

Little Claire gets a special new stuffed toy for her birthday, Dalmatian Polkadot, but one of her old toys, Witch, is jealous. She magics Dalmatian’s spots to Fairyland and all the other toys have to journey there to retrieve them. In this musical…

The Railway Children

12 Aug 20103 stars

A classic revisited

Rather than cater to contemporary children’s experiences, Sell a Door Theatre Company has gone for a faithful rendition of a classic. E. Nesbit’s well-loved tale of Mrs Waterbury and her three children, who are forced to move to the country while her…

Could it Be Forever?

12 Aug 20103 stars

A bittersweet comedy will have you recall youthful emotion

Six schoolfriends reunite after 37 years to remember an eventful week during which they were in thrall to David Cassidy in this bittersweet comedy about first loves, friendships and the unexpected course of life. Whether you were a pop picker in 1973 or…

back to top

Ray Bradbury’s 2116

12 Aug 20103 stars

A dreamy fairytale about the perils of creating perfection

Creepy. Macabre. Childish. Puppets are dangerously captivating. In this new musical by speculative fiction guru Ray Bradbury Mr Marionette leads a dreamy gothic fairytale about the perils of creating perfection. The production, masterminded by…

Suspicious Package

11 Aug 20103 stars

Immersive fun on the streets of Edinburgh

If you’re in a shop in the Grassmarket or on Victoria Street and see some people in daft hats having a stilted conversation read from iPods you’ve probably stumbled across a ‘performance’ of this interactive promenade piece. After being greeted by…

Jason Cook

11 Aug 20104 stars

Well-crafted, life-affirming stuff

It’s a cliché that comedians just want to be loved, but Jason Cook tries awfully hard to endear himself. Welcoming the audience into The End (Part 1), he lightly teases a few individuals, joshes with a reviewer he recognises and seeks advice and…

Arj Barker

11 Aug 20102 stars

Disappointing gaggery from much-hyped actor

At the top of the show, Arj Barker promises fresh material, points out the contemporary fashion for honesty and vulnerability in comedy, and (whether fairly or not) has drawn a sell-out crowd due to being Dave from Flight of the Conchords. Sounds good…

The Blue Lady Sings

11 Aug 20104 stars

A free cabaret-style show full of humour and skill

Tricity Vogue is blue. Not depressed, literally painted blue. She sings the blues and other lyrically relevant songs. She is also a painting, although slightly unhinged and occasionally escaping her frame. Romping through a series of cabaret-style skits…

back to top

New Art Club

11 Aug 20104 stars

Original, charming and very funny

A best-of compilation from the comedy dance duo (who can actually dance) in which Tom Roden and Pete Shenton replay their best bits. Loyal fans and Johnny-come-latelys get to see minimalist experimental pieces, clever wordy numbers and downright silly…

Rob Rouse

11 Aug 20103 stars

Spinning the mundane into the finest yarn

So, what have you been up to? A half-decent comedian should be able to cobble together an entertaining answer to this simple premise and Rouse doesn’t disappoint. Without high concept, gimmick or whimsy, he relates incidents from his recent move to the…

Memory Cells

10 Aug 20103 stars

Exploring the machinations of power

Louise Welsh excels at excavating the dark and depraved aspects of the human psyche, eking out secret desires and fears. In this dialogue between a beautiful captive girl and her love-deluded jailer, not much else is given away by the brutal staging…

Storm Large - Crazy Enough

9 Aug 20104 stars

A musical memoir with bawdy tales

Storm Large is absolutely gorgeous, what with her mile-long legs, blonde locks and cherubic face. But I think she expects us to be shocked with all her talk about fisting. The American rock chick will learn that Fringe audiences have a high capacity for…

Jungle Book: The Next Chapter

9 Aug 20102 stars

Monkeying around with Kipling’s classic

Rudyard Kipling’s fables are part of the collective national psyche, so this follow-up from Glenn Elston and the Australian Shakespeare Company has a lot to live up to. The story picks up when Mowgli, now grown, returns to the jungle to visit Baloo.