Edinburgh Festival Guide

Reviews & features: Sam Healy

Sorted by date / title / rating.

James Dowdeswell

23 Aug 20102 stars

Mediocre material and rather uneasy delivery

You want to like him, you really do. And in another context maybe this gentle show about Dowdeswell’s discovery that his great-grandfather worked with Charlie Chaplin would pass muster. Alas, his mediocre material and rather uneasy delivery are roundly…

WitTank

20 Aug 20104 stars

High-octane/high-brow character comedy

Now whittled down to a lean and confident trio, WitTank’s evolution into a formidable sketch troupe is arguably complete. Performances are accomplished without being distant or over-rehearsed. Pacing is fluid yet relentless. Material is frequently…

Ian D Montfort

16 Aug 20103 stars

Some great shambolics and ad-libbing

This promising new character from Tom Binns (creator of hospital DJ Ivan Brackenbury) is a Sunderland ‘actual psychic’ who can talk to dead celebrities as well as deceased aunties. Some great shambolics and ad-libbing are let down a bit by occasionally…

The Boy With Tape On His Face

12 Aug 20105 stars

A masterclass of mime

The blunt, artless title sets the tone. Kiwi comedian Sam Wills is indeed gagged by gaffer tape, for the whole hour. Not a word is spoken. And what might have fallen flat, as the indulgent experiment of lopping a supposedly essential element off an…

Matt Green

24 Aug 20093 stars

Hard to fault any specific aspect of his act

Green's material is fine. His delivery is fine. It's hard to fault any specific aspect of his act. Yet the fine whole flatly refuses to be more than its parts' sum. Eagerness to please moves him to defang his more interesting, darker stuff with giggles…

back to top

Ross Lee

24 Aug 20092 stars

Sometimes entertaining but mostly depressing

A fame junkie since his gauche childhood in Leeds, Lee presents a video documentary of his own obsessive attempts to be on TV, culminating in a stint as a Nickelodeon UK host. His evident monomaniacal lust for the merest crust of renown is sometimes…

Danielle Ward

23 Aug 20093 stars

Self-aware yet distinctive act

Danielle Ward is not, it emerges quickly, your common or garden aide-mémoire comic, reheating pre-cooked observations and serving them on a Styrofoam plate of uninvested playing-at-caring. Her thematic inventiveness is evident from the first skit, a…

Tom Deacon

20 Aug 20092 stars

Fairly ordinary romp through an indecisive mind

The choice of Kasabian’s ‘Fire’ as the walk-on music for Tom Deacon’s show is telling. It establishes a checklist of expectations which go utterly unchallenged during the subsequent hour of serviceable, unremarkable, rut-deepening comedy. Young Deacon…

Unsupervised Detention

19 Aug 20093 stars

Tight sketch comedy by gifted young players

Tight sketch comedy by gifted young players and, though some scenes suffer from a too-actorly approach, there are more hits than misses and evidence of a genuine facility with the surreal. The introductory premise of bored schoolkids in detention…

Wil Hodgson

18 Aug 20093 stars

The nicest pink-haired ex-punk on earth

In his sixth visit to the Fringe, the nicest pink-haired ex-punk on earth entertains with tales from his chiaroscuro existence in Chippenham. Stories of his characterful drinking buddies, encounters with stripling bigots and bittersweet nostalgia are…

back to top

The Bodega Brothers

18 Aug 20094 stars

Laconic, self-deprecating and funny

Comparisons with a certain Kiwi folk-parody duo are inevitable. Rob Castell and Tom Sadler play acoustic guitars and sing comedy songs. They do so very well. Their stage banter is laconic, self-deprecating and funny. Bret and Jemaine might not be…

Rudi Lickwood

18 Aug 20092 stars

Old-fashioned delivery and desperately prosaic observations

It’s not a good sign when a wilfully confrontational show comes off as bland and pedestrian. Lickwood has some funny lines and makes a few good points, but his fatally old-fashioned delivery and desperately prosaic observations on Britain’s ethnic…

Glenn Wool

18 Aug 20094 stars

Has never been funnier or more lustily discombobulated

This disreputable Canadian soapboxer is truly in the ascendant. A perfectly realised tragicomic stage persona (or maybe Glenn is just being Glenn), great lines, heartfelt rage and a skewed but intimate audience rapport make for a rousing, boisterous…

Mould & Arrowsmith

18 Aug 20094 stars

Playful and ingeniously funny

Beyond nerdy, yet playful and ingeniously funny, Steve Mould and Gemma Arrowsmith’s mock-highbrow revue is like a Centre Georges Pompidou of comedy: all exposed plumbing, postmodern form-as-content and paradox fetishism. Hauling a wide load of…

Abracadabra: German Humour Goes Global

18 Aug 20093 stars

Enjoyable, non-ironically zany knees-up

Germany’s best and, by a remarkable coincidence, only international English-language stand-up duo delivers another enjoyable, non-ironically zany knees-up for us Tommies. Henning Wehn is a born comedian even in his second tongue; Otto Kuhnle provides…

back to top

The Dark Party

16 Aug 20093 stars

Gothic sideshow for the Top Gear set

Unsure of whether it wants to be physical comedy, gross-out sideshow or gothic visual poetry, this unique hour just about delivers on all three fronts. Shep Huntly, Patrick Bath and Gordo Gamsby (collectively The Dirty Brothers) are dressed in…

Aindrias de Staic - The Summer I Did The Leaving

14 Aug 20092 stars

For fiddle-fanciers and Hibernophiles only

The Summer I Did The Leaving recalls a seminal season in the youth of fiddler, raconteur and all-round rudderless hippie Aindrias de Staic (the Leaving Certificate is the Irish equivalent of the Scottish Highers). Through song and story he revisits…

Keith Farnan

11 Aug 20094 stars

A natural comedic talent

Freshly bearded and with a polished hour of new material on racism, intolerance and the literal luck of the Irish, Farnan is in firm control of his pacy, compassionate show. His natural charm bridges the occasional dry spell, and the overall impression…

Jojo Sutherland

11 Aug 20092 stars

An autobiographical tale of a not very interesting life

Sutherland is a frank middle-aged woman who has led a more interesting life than most. Sadly she seems to think that this plus a few threadbare jokes are enough to carry her autobiographical show. They’re not. Unless your thing is sitting in on a group…

Sarah Millican

8 Aug 20093 stars

Facing up to gender politics and the elements

The unflappable Geordie lass looks a bit intimidating on the Mr Muscle-themed poster for her new show, but a minute in her company reassures us that the butch press campaign is just skylarking. Last year’s if.comedy Best Newcomer is in flying form, with…

back to top

Fool Koller

21 Aug 20083 stars

Wet feral fun from Dutch pratfaller

The ambit of what has not yet been done shrinks ever smaller. Pity the poor alternative comedians, clutching at auxiliary originalities as the pool of unprecedented material ebbs to nothing: slicker, quicker jokes, more postmodernism, cynicism…

Goodbye Goodbye

21 Aug 20083 stars

Strappingly acted, cleverly written and innovatively staged, this intriguing narrative sketch show is let down by its indecision. At times it's content with its many funny lines and characters, at others it seems to lust vainly after an earnest…

Newsrevue

14 Aug 20082 stars

Satire that fails to hit the target

Consisting entirely of up-to-the-minute topical satire skits, this all-singing, all-dancing soapbox couldn't be more contemporary. Yet there's something desperately antiquated about it, something broad and music hall. In theory this is no bad thing.

David O'Doherty

14 Aug 20084 stars

Finding gold in the everyday dirt

By the end of his self-introduction, before he's even reached the stage, David O'Doherty has his audience braying like donkeys. The Dublin comic has done so many consistently enjoyable Fringe shows that getting laughs must be like shooting fish in a…

Johnny Candon

14 Aug 20083 stars

A lean, likeable and sporadically funny show that rises to the challenge set by its timeslot. Dubliner Candon riffs on themes of his adoption, fatherhood and arachnophobia with wit and easy charm. He's one of those sweet-talkers who can say 'fuck' to a…