Edinburgh Festival Guide

Reviews & features: Rebecca Ross

Sorted by date / title / rating.

Asher Treleaven: Matador

23 Aug 20114 stars

Fresh, exciting and energetic

There’s no explanation for the rose-trimmed, front-lawn stage Treleaven spends the hour dandying around, but this seems to fit in with his marvellously peculiar persona. His bittersweet harangue on racism is as intelligent and heartfelt as it is funny.

Mark Dolan

23 Aug 20113 stars

Genial bumbling and his confident stage presence is charming and droll

Ranting about everyday ills could quickly become dour, but Dolan’s genial bumbling, juxtaposed with his confident stage presence is charming and droll. His ability to make mundane chatter with the audience quaintly humorous is his real selling point…

Tom Bell Begins

23 Aug 20112 stars

Tangent tales turn too often into ramblings

Formerly in duo Tommy and the Weeks, Bell’s solo show has more tangents than a geometry textbook. This sometimes works well, in strange spiels that play to his effervescent oddness, but mostly the performance is inconsistent, turning too frequently into…

Mabbs & Justice: Love Machine

23 Aug 20112 stars

Joke on characters’ thespian shortcomings tragically bypasses irony

James Mabbett and Adam Justice are questionable actors and, as M&J, a bit annoying. There are some averagely amusing moments, and effective use of a projector, but the show’s main joke is the characters’ thespian shortcomings, which tragically bypasses…

Michael Workman - Humans Are Beautiful

16 Aug 20113 stars

Surreal, meditative show from philosophical, esoteric intellect

In this surreal, meditative show Workman spins an impressively sustained yarn about his journey through a warzone accompanied by a talking dog and his grave-digging love interest. His philosophical, esoteric intellect is tangible beneath the surface of…

back to top

Phil Nichol: The Simple Hour

16 Aug 20113 stars

Dumbed down silliness peppered with droll quips

An hour in Nichol’s company seems to canter by in the wake of the comic’s own upbeat and vociferous performance. However, the material is constantly in danger of descending into vacuity, and although he peppers the silliness with droll quips, the…

The Ginge, the Geordie and the Geek

15 Aug 20113 stars

Feel-good comedy from the sketch-happy threesome

In this veritable zip-wire of a show the three Gs whiz through characters from garden gnomes to mime addicts. The timing and production are truly remarkable, and there’s absolutely nothing to dislike about these lads, whose genuine enthusiasm is…

Nick Helm - Dare to Dream

12 Aug 20113 stars

Shouty Marmite musical act

Nick Helm is whipping up quite a storm on the comedy circuit, and you can see why. He is certainly a force to be reckoned with: confident, commanding, and able to straddle the line between brusque, brash delivery, and engaging moments of…

Catriona Knox

8 Aug 20112 stars

Signs of promise but dialogue lacks punch

The platter of characters here are, at best, well-acted and have the right foundations to be spun into entertaining sketches. However, the dialogue doesn’t pack enough punch and the material quickly grates; that doesn’t deter Knox, who even returns to…

Dregs

8 Aug 20113 stars

Character-based sketches maintain constant audience engagement

Max Dickins and Mark Smith present an hour which thrives on its unpredictability, offering character-based sketches while maintaining a constant audience engagement. The show takes slightly too long to gather momentum, after an awkward start, and would…

back to top

Brown and Corley: Born in the 80s

8 Aug 20111 star

Like bad school drama production

This is like watching a bad school drama production – where those involved aren’t your offspring, you’re not obliged to laugh. Brown is relentlessly abrasive, which makes Corley’s blandness a comparative blessing. The best thing about it is the…

Sex You (I’m Gonna) – featuring Nathan Phillips

8 Aug 20112 stars

More sophisticated than it advertises itself to be

Like the ‘grower, not show-er penis’ that Nathan Phillips tells us about, this act sells itself short, proving mercifully more sophisticated than it advertises itself to be; in fact, he’s quite the gentleman. The inescapable problem is that it doesn’t…

Matt Rudge

8 Aug 20112 stars

Natural warmth let down by meandering dialogue

While he’s the sort of nice, respectable boy you might take home to meet your mother, Rudge isn’t lighting any fires in this lolloping show, which features meandering dialogue and humour with little spark. The routine seems a bit too earnestly…

Vinegar Knickers

5 Aug 20112 stars

A well-titled ‘sketchy beast’

Sketchy just about sums this show up. Despite high-energy, enthusiastic performances from Samantha Baines, Katie Burnetts and Harriet Fisher, like a cheap chicken Caesar salad the meaty bits are too few and far between, and the ‘lettuce’ material is…

Seymour Mace

25 Aug 20104 stars

Odd, witty and unexpected gags galore

Since Mace has been accused of not putting enough of himself into his performance, he has thrown his whole lazy self into this year’s show. You’ll get a whole different kettle of joke to that of the mainstream Festival here with odd, witty and…

back to top

The Gentleman of Leisure

25 Aug 20103 stars

Engaging and sharp

Tom Neenan and Nish Kumar are The Gentlemen of Leisure, bringing you an energetic and enlightening hour of satire and silliness. Although a little more on-stage chemistry between the pair wouldn’t go amiss, the duo are engaging and sharp, and pull off…

Shappi Khorsandi

23 Aug 20103 stars

Falls disappointingly short of expectations

As Khorsandi’s reputation sky-rockets, her material about divorce and single motherhood falls disappointingly short of expectations. The show loses momentum for perceptible periods of time and if the jokes are a tad lacklustre, Khorsandi herself is…

Susan Murray

23 Aug 20103 stars

Interesting and intelligent

Murray’s bold and playful set is nothing less than you’d expect from a Weegie with a Brummie accent. Although the show isn’t necessarily joke-heavy, this lady has done her research and the material is interesting and intelligent, particularly as Murray…

Crumpets, Muffins and Afternoon Teas(e)

16 Aug 20102 stars

More unease than tease

Tammy Stone is an accomplished vocalist somewhat wasted on a set of bitter songs, too many of which end with the objet d’amour being killed and eaten by the bonkers songstress. Her lyrics have the potential to spin the gloriously inappropriate into…

Wendy Wason

16 Aug 20102 stars

Intelligent, heartfelt and entertaining

Most of us tend to avoid airing our dirty laundry in public, but Wendy Wason is determined to squeeze secrets from every nook and cranny including family, friends and celebrities: not even her audience is safe. Wason is a natural-born chatterbox and her…

back to top

Lee Nelson

11 Aug 20102 stars

If his game is satire he keeps it well hidden

Simon Brodkin seems to have carved a niche for himself as mouthy chav Lee Nelson, and what’s not to love about him shouting, swearing and crotch-grabbing? The mind boggles. If you’re prone to a boggling mind, or are hot on sentence conjugation, this one…

Nathan Caton

11 Aug 20103 stars

Tackles issues of race with refreshing ease and sensitivity

After Breakfast at Stephanie’s, you’ll have got to know the whole Caton family. Nathan Caton is perfectly endearing, and his observations on family life are at once sharp and accessible: that unabashedly racist or generally ‘un-PC’ geriatric relative…

Geraldine Quinn

10 Aug 20103 stars

Flash your flesh, your cash and your camel toe

In an era of ‘pop with no pants’, Geraldine Quinn explains how to be a singing sensation, even if you can’t sing: flash your flesh, your cash and your camel toe. Vivacious and confident, Quinn mercifully can hit a note, and her lyrics are wry and…

Tony Law

10 Aug 20102 stars

Some laugh-worthy material

Tony Law is by his own admission ‘loud and annoying’ and he has hit the nail on the head. The comic has some laugh-worthy material in his Brainporium, but it’s buried under the detritus of rambling, non-sequiturs and, at a particularly painful point…

Ray Green

9 Aug 20104 stars

The 3D adventures of a two-bit character

Ray Green is an unabashed serial bumbler and the alter ego of Preston-born Dave Gibson. With a down-to-earth Northern charm and a moustache – the latter comes in handy when reaffirming your virility or being mugged, apparently – Gibson/Green’s hour of a…