Edinburgh Festival Guide

Reviews & features: Fringe

Sorted by date / title / rating.

Love Letters to the Public Transport System

21 Aug 20123 stars

Life-affirming monologue celebrates society’s unsung heroes

The premise of Molly Taylor’s monologue sounds, in summary, so precious you wouldn’t expect it to work as a piece of drama. In 2009, following a painful break-up and the loss of her permanent job, Taylor travelled by bus to London where a chance meeting…

Luke Benson - Backseat Hero

21 Aug 20122 stars

Deadpan delivery and thin material get lost in the void

Bravely diverging from the ‘genial Geordie’ archetype, Luke Benson (aka Skywalker aka The Bensonator) has a deadpan, monotone delivery that fits well with his tales of urban discontent and gangly outsiderness (he’s 6’ 7”). Unfortunately this nuance is…

David O'Doherty

21 Aug 20123 stars

Well-executed show on dark times wears thin

Fringe favourite David O'Doherty returns to Edinburgh with his new show show 'Seize the David O'Doherty'. The Irishman, whose appearances on Never Mind The Buzzcocks catapulted him in to the public eye, fuses a dry and subtle wit, self-depreciating…

Al Pitcher - Tiny Triumphs

21 Aug 20123 stars

A funny if unchallenging appreciation of life’s little amusements

Most people are too busy to stop and appreciate life’s small absurdities, but not Al Pitcher. He spends his days taking photos of things that amuse him, then presents a slideshow of his results at that evening’s performance. It’s a performance style…

Lights! Camera! Improvise!

21 Aug 20124 stars

Giving improv a good name

Banish all preconceived notions of improv being cringey or stilted, as there are no such qualms when it comes to the Scat Pack troupe. The premise is to create an entire film from scratch, directed by a chirpy host (Oscar, naturally) who pauses…

back to top

Jigsaw - Gettin' Jiggy

21 Aug 20124 stars

Top sketch comedy from Dan Antopolski, Nat Luurtsema and Tom Craine

After a successful Fringe debut last year, the troupe return with another offering of what has to be one of the fastest-paced sketch shows about. Some skits last less than a minute before we’re plunged into the next. Stand-ups Dan Antopolski (the…

Four Screws Loose

21 Aug 20122 stars

Intelligently conceived highlights rare in show that is largely filler

Sketch show foursome Four Screws Loose set out to find a comedic juxtapose of pantomime-style tomfoolery and the bizarre. The show opens with a music led and flamboyant introduction that, whilst prompting the obligatory audience clap-along, is old…

Silky

21 Aug 20123 stars

Liverpudlian comic is keen to please but able to disturb

Unlike other performers that have descended on Edinburgh throughout the festival, Silky has opted not to plaster his posters around town. Going against the publicity grain, the comedian has instead placed his PR material on the underside of buses; and…

Wuthering Heights

20 Aug 20123 stars

Emily Brontë adaptation by young Cardiff players is a praiseworthy production

Rarely has fiction portrayed the negative as well as positive emotions of love than in Emily Brontë’s masterpiece. Heathcliff and Cathy's passionate, never harmonious yearning is, of course, at the heart of the story, yet the novel's complex narrative…

Monkey Bars

20 Aug 20125 stars

Kids say the profoundest things

‘Sometimes adults don’t really listen to children,’ suggests the actor playing dialogue artist Karl James at the start of Chris Goode’s masterful new verbatim play. And that’s exactly what this astonishing piece seems to be telling us – that there’s so…

back to top

Bigmouth

20 Aug 20125 stars

Enthralling roller-coaster through history and its (in)humanity by Valentijn Dhaenens

‘History not merely touches on language, but takes place in it.’ This quote from the German philosopher Adorno could summarise the underlying themes of SkaGeN’s Bigmouth. The show makes the (perhaps not obvious connection) between figures of great…

Red, Like Our Room Used to Feel

20 Aug 20125 stars

Inspirational one-on-one poetry experience with Ryan Van Winkle

Poetry readings have often suffered from small audiences. Ryan Van Winkle has worked that to his advantage: the size of the audience for Red, Like Our Room Used To Feel is precisely one. And that’s why it works. There is nothing scary or awkward…

Paperbelle

20 Aug 20125 stars

Imaginative fun for the very young

Creating a show that straddles the fine line between engaging a pre-schooler, and not scaring them, isn’t easy. Harder still to capture the imagination of the grown-up whose lap they’re sitting on or next to. Yet with this delicate, sweet and funny…

Matthew Crosby

20 Aug 20123 stars

Slightly stilted affair from an otherwise very funny man

Given the majesty of this year’s main Pappy’s show, we can surely forgive Matthew Crosby (the small, bespectacled, beardy one of the trio) if he’s not firing on the same number of cylinders that powered his 2011 solo debut. Even so, he is able to…

Felicity Ward: The Hedgehog Dilemma

20 Aug 20124 stars

High-speed hour of breathless laughs from charismatic comedienne

One way to freshen up material about relationships is to frame it in a cute thought experiment. Imagine two hedgehogs getting ready for winter. Do they cuddle together, and risk hurting each other with their spines? Or do they sit apart, not getting…

back to top

Beats

20 Aug 20124 stars

Tremendous recreation of rave culture

Tremendous recreation of rave culture In 1994 the UK Criminal Justice and Public Order Act outlawed gatherings of more than 100 people with a soundtrack of ‘amplified music characterised by the emission of a succession of repetitive beats’. In the…

Carl Donnelly: Different Gravy

20 Aug 20123 stars

A tickling rather than side-splitting hour from home-made autobiography writer

Carl Donnelly is a nice guy. Beginning his routine with a slide-show (before he gets on stage) of his home-made autobiography cover and jokey snaps of family and friends, it’s clear that here is someone not afraid to take the piss out of himself, never…

Uninvited

20 Aug 20122 stars

Ambitious production fails to spring to life

Our unnamed protagonist, obsessed by order and routine, returns home from work to discover a stranger in his house. So he makes him a cup of tea. But that’s the least of his worries: the talking wallpaper seems to have opinions on everything, and his…

Guardian Reader

20 Aug 20123 stars

Liberal leftie humour from William Hammer-Lloyd

The anonymous reader is a tall, lanky, floppy-haired, bearded, liberal, leftie, upper-middle class intellectual and former teacher. In other words, he’s the archetypal reader of the newspaper affectionately known as The Grauniad. Having become all too…

John Conway - The New Conway Dimension

20 Aug 20123 stars

Small and daft is the order of the day in Conway's semi-anarchic routines

If you find yourself tiring of the slick, professional, often identikit comedians in town, you should cop a load of Australia’s John Conway. With laptop-wielding sidekick Michael Burke trying his utmost to keep proceedings reasonably on track, Conway…

back to top

Boris and Sergey’s Vaudevillian Adventure

20 Aug 20123 stars

Droll and bawdy puppet double act

Droll and bawdy puppet double act Nothing covers cracks like cuteness. Boris and Sergey are two faceless leather bunraku puppets that look like reconstituted old footballs sprung to life. They speak in gravelly Russian honks and have more than enough…

Out of the Blue

20 Aug 20124 stars

All-male a cappella group radiate charm with formidable vocals and infectious stage presence

Before a 500-strong, sold-out Saturday house, 15 young men shimmy onto a lights-down, mist-shrouded stage, to be greeted thunderously from what seems to be most of the visiting female population of Edinburgh. Out of the Blue is back. In their…

Steve Shanyaski’s Life-Survival Bible

20 Aug 20122 stars

Perfectly pleasant jokes masking an aimless set-up

Shanyaski is an all-guns-blazing kinda guy, barrelling onstage and wasting no time ingratiating himself to a late-night crowd. His is a show, he promises, that will help the hapless sods among us to navigate the challenges of everyday life, his…

And They Played Shang-a-Lang

20 Aug 20123 stars

Bay City Rollers jukebox musical is boisterous good fun

If a semi-autobiographical jukebox musical about salad days in Scotland sounds grim -- and it should -- Derek Douglas’ nostalgia fest is surprisingly good fun. Local amateur company Craft Theatre’s 15-strong cast perform with such gusto and evident…

Colin Mars: A Life Full of Lemons

20 Aug 20121 star

Over-egged and unoriginal fare

Life may have given Mars his fair share of lemons, but instead of making lemonade, a yawnworthy theme he continually comes back to, he's squeezed the metaphorical citrus dry leaving nothing but a sour pulp. Nervous and sweaty, the three-strong audience…