Edinburgh Festival Guide

Reviews & features: Comedy

Sorted by date / title / rating.

Sammy J & Randy - The Inheritance

19 Aug 20123 stars

Triumph of style over substance

Yes, it’s funny that a purple puppet might swear and drink and smoke. And it’s probably amusing that he would hang out with a socially inadequate skinny nerd. But once you get used to those facts, and have nodded in admiration at the production values…

Taylor Glenn - Reverse Psycomedy

19 Aug 20123 stars

Playing mind games with her crowd

There can’t be too many Fringe comedy shows (ie zero) that casually drop in phrases such as ‘cognitive behaviour’, ‘Gestalt theory’ or ‘psychodynamic therapy’. But then, not many Fringe comedians will have worked for eight years as a professional…

Gareth Morinan

19 Aug 20123 stars

Slim pickings amid a frenzy of facts

Quite a busy boy is Gareth Morinan given that he has seven different shows at the Fringe including political debates, a bit of improv and spoken word events in which he speaks out about his opinions on David Cameron and Ricky Gervais (he’s not a fan of…

The Not Quite Quartet

19 Aug 20123 stars

High fives and top tunes

If you have yet to make your way through The Wire or somehow haven’t yet seen Fight Club or The Sixth Sense or Citizen Kane, best take some earplugs with you to The Not Quite Quartet. ‘The Spoiler Song’ does exactly what it says in the title but it…

Sam Fletcher - Good on Paper

19 Aug 20123 stars

Weird and wacky mix of magic and music

There has been a surge in self-deprecating geeky comics over the last few years, reflecting a kind of postmodern twist of fate. Being a nerd has become cool, and Sam Fletcher’s weird and wacky show – a mix of crude magic, flipchart proposals and ‘dad…

back to top

Chris Ramsey

19 Aug 20124 stars

Warm tales from a hugely charismatic performer

Quite why Chris Ramsey is so surprised by his popularity, it’s hard to tell. A nominee of last year’s Edinburgh Comedy Award, he cannot believe his luck and claims to be having the time of his life. This concept of good fortune forms the basis of his…

Alexis Dubus: Cars & Girls

19 Aug 20123 stars

Too much of a good thing

This exuberant English comedian is too clever for his own good. Alexis Dubus’ new show draws upon some seriously crazy travel adventures he’s undertaken, including a trip to – and at – the psychedelic Burning Man Festival in the American desert. What…

James Acaster

19 Aug 20124 stars

Brings joy to surreal and eccentric comedy

A criticism levelled at James Acaster over the last couple of years is that his material has been somewhat puerile. He’s been tipped as a young comedian with real potential but still in need of much improvement, something far from the truth in this…

Going Green the Wong Way

17 Aug 20122 stars

Joyous but ultimately pointless one-woman eco-show

Joyous but ultimately pointless one-woman eco-show Displaced San Franciscan Katrina Wong is a dedicated environmentalist: her school-age performance poetry about the rape of Mother Earth gave way to her first job canvassing for conservationist…

Man 1 Bank 0

17 Aug 20123 stars

Patrick Combs takes on the money men

Half the challenge of putting on a great show at the Fringe is about finding a great story, and Patrick Combs certainly has that. Better still, it’s true. A young man, with a sea of credit card debt, deposits a $95,093.35 junk mail cheque into his local…

back to top

David Whitney – Struggling to Evolve

15 Aug 20121 star

Ill-conceived, unhappy show featuring cheap gags and little intelligence

Blasting his way onto the expectant stage with a hefty set of bagpipes, you could probably cite this loud start as the highlight of Whitney’s set. The tired-looking comedian immediately conceded (unnecessarily) that the bagpipes were a gimmick – before…

FNT Live presents … The Jingling Lane Family Singers

15 Aug 20122 stars

Funny bits few and far between in ill-executed sketch comedy

At the start of this doomed sketch affair, there are more people on stage than in the crowd. Given that FNT Live features ten members, that’s not as cringeworthy as it might sound. The opening features an American family of fundamentalist Christian…

Fred MacAulay

15 Aug 20124 stars

Persistently strong material and natural affability from Fringe institution

Now a firm Fringe institution, Fred MacAulay could coast by on easy charm alone. But that would never do, and even when he tackles well-trodden topics like air travel there's always the safe feeling that he'll have put in the graft for a proper big…

The Three Englishmen: Squares

15 Aug 20123 stars

Gently amusing sketches could do with more pep to fulfil likeable lads' potential

The Three Englishmen – there’s four of them actually – aren’t blazing a new sketch comedy trail in in this show. But it’s a gently amusing hour with some stand out moments of hilarity, thanks primarily to their musical skills. The boys welcome us…

Bruce Hammers' Bananapocalypse

15 Aug 20123 stars

Gloriously chaotic hour that tumbles through fictitious film legend's career

Relative newcomer Mat Ewins 'stars' as Bruce Hammers, 1980's film legend best known for his seminal work the 1982 film Bananapocalypse. That's about as much as you get that's sensical about this show, it's a gloriously chaotic hour that tumbles through…

back to top

Funk Rocket 5000

15 Aug 20123 stars

Rachel Lancaster is brilliant in this off-kilter mental health comedy

The lights in the venue have blown – again – and the stage is cast in the sickly green glow of the emergency back-up. It couldn’t be better for this brilliantly bleak, bone-dry mental health comedy, which suggests the boundaries between patient and…

Unhappy Birthday

15 Aug 20124 stars

Less a show than a mad Dadaist happening

‘It’s a party-slash-show-slash party!’ Such is Amy Lamé’s breathless refrain, which she repeats manically, with the excitement of an eight-year-old hopped up on Party Ring e-numbers. In fact, Unhappy Birthday is less a show than a mad Dadaist happening…

Tania Edwards - Killer Instinct

15 Aug 20122 stars

Funny Women finalist in career regression

Straight off the bat, the eminently likeable Tania Edwards insists that this is going to be her year. It’s ‘break or breakdown’ time. Unfortunately, several things could be conspiring against her as she moves ahead with her grand plans (which may have…

I Am, I Am

15 Aug 20124 stars

Highly entertaining slapstick minstrelry from promising troubadour comedy duo

For ones so young it's obscene how much confidence these duelling acoustic troubadours from Cambridge have. With their genre shifting ditties and punning rhymes I Am, I Am are most obviously comparable to The Flight of the Conchords but their very…

Edinburgh Festival Fringe 2012: Comedy highlights so far

14 Aug 2012

Dr Brown, Shit-Faced Shakespeare, Alfie Brown, Jim Jefferies and more

Dr Brown Mr Phil Burgers gets stuck into some quality hushed clowning work for his adult crowd with surprisingly tender results. See review at list.co.uk/festival. Underbelly, Cowgate, 0844 545 8252, until 26 Aug (not 20), 9.05pm, £10.50--£11.50…

back to top

Ford & Akram

14 Aug 20123 stars

Warm, charismatic show from the bumbling comedy duo

Female duo Yasmine Akram and Louise Ford sit side by side in silence. As the former beams a radiant smile, the latter glares glumly in to the front row. Embarking on a voyage to fulfill an elderly relatives last request the show consists of a…

Detention

14 Aug 20123 stars

Mr Bean meets Olympic gymnastics: physical comedy, Hong Kong style

Hong Kong show Detention is a highly accomplished example of a form of physical comedy that is extremely popular in east Asia. If you haven’t encountered this kind of work on the Edinburgh Fringe in the past, think Mr Bean crossed with Olympic…

Mr Braithwaite Has a New Boy

14 Aug 20122 stars

Decent performances can’t redeem predictable Aussie farce

With this new comedy by Steven Dawson (who also directs and designs it), Melbourne’s LGBT-focused theatre company Out Cast Theatre plays lazily to the crowd, favouring lashings of none-too-subtle and none-too-imaginative cheap smut and broadly-drawn…

Discover Ben Target

14 Aug 20124 stars

Prop-heavy, unpredictable riot is a triumph of chaos-masked complexity

Throughout Discover Ben Target the gathered punters are taken on numerous bizarre and wonderful journeys. The first, a figurative express trip from “This is unusual” to “Why-in-shitting-hell-are-we-not-sitting-at-the-back?” to the last; a casual stroll…

Trevor Noah: The Racist

13 Aug 20124 stars

Identity crisis makes for hilarious comedy

It takes a particular kind of individual to get up on stage and open their soul to a room of strangers in order to achieve ratification for their existence. Part of that drive might come from the oft-cited routes about having learned to use humour to…