Edinburgh Festival Guide

Reviews & features: Comedy

Sorted by date / title / rating.

Who’s Your Daddy?

23 Aug 20122 stars

Poorly presented account of Johnny O’Callaghan's bizarre true-life tale

Johnny O’Callaghan went to Africa in the pits of a deep depression in the hope that spending time there would somehow increase his chances of dying. He came back the father of a small Ugandan boy. His one-man show, starkly set and told, it feels, in…

Dana Alexander: Breaking Through

23 Aug 20122 stars

Desperately Seeking the Exit might be more fitting title for fly-by show

A theme seems to be emerging from several reviews of Dana Alexander’s 2012 Fringe show. She just doesn’t seem to adapt very well to playing in front of a small audience. Of course, it’s not ideal for any comic, but the old maxim surely must apply: ‘the…

Paul Foot - Kenny Larch Is Dead

23 Aug 20123 stars

A creature of habit delivers his usual fantastical fare

The structure of a Paul Foot gig is by now pretty well-established. Kick off with a bizarre non sequitur, move onto the next surreal musing, go a bit stir crazy, take ages over insignificant details, suffer a stage breakdown and then depart to a hero’s…

Neil Delamere: DelaMere Mortal

23 Aug 20123 stars

Safe but solid hour of craic

With such an easy-going manner and propensity for chatty audience banter, it helps if Neil Delamere can scoop out an interesting front-row character or two. And on this occasion, he uncovers a children’s author and the son of a notable ITV newsreader in…

Roisin Conaty: Lifehunter

23 Aug 20124 stars

Life-affirming show from joy-seeker comedienne

Lifehunter, explains Conaty, is all about searching for the ultimate happiness, a pursuit in which she is extremely well versed. With a forthright manner, like she’s your bubbly blonde mate and we’re all down the pub, Conaty weaves elaborate tales about…

back to top

Bristol Revunions: Destination Adventure

23 Aug 20123 stars

Stepping up their sketch act to a new level

The cool kids down at Bristol Revunions (quite a clumsy moniker that) have come up with a pretty ingenious avenue into their sketches this year. Not for them the gruesome donning of gimp masks or overly cosy slipping-on of jimmy-jams, as members of the…

Carl Hutchinson: Acceptable?

23 Aug 20123 stars

A pleasingly moody debut from 25 year old Geordie comic

Having spent a mere 25 years on this planet, it might be far too soon for rising Geordie comic Carl Hutchinson to be a grumpy old man. But he gives those fractious celebrity gents a run for their moaning money with his debut hour. Acceptable is an…

Kieran and Joe: Friends of Steel

23 Aug 20123 stars

Mercurial chemistry in pair's solidly entertaining double act

This masterclass in friendship is more of a lesson in intimidation as Kieran Hodgson and Joe Parham put the living fear into a front row which could be plucked from and experimented on at any moment. Now ploughing on as a trimmed-down double act (yes…

It's Grimm Up North

23 Aug 20121 star

Animated character grotesquesset in fictional Hardington leave you cold

The first two episodes of this animated series introduce us to a handful of characters - through stories based on fairy tales and fables - who live in the fictional town of Hardington. The animation is distinctive and quirky and the first film in…

Peacock and Gamble

23 Aug 20123 stars

No TV deal just yet for comedic spacehoppers

While they proclaim that they aren’t especially fussed about never being on TV, Ray Peacock and Ed Gamble may be biting their tongues somewhat. Certainly, there must be somewhere (a late-night corner on BBC Three?) for their ill-fitting partnership to…

back to top

Michael Workman - Mercy

23 Aug 20124 stars

A beautiful blend of images, music, storytelling and comedy

This is a truly beautiful little show; a quirky blend of images, music, storytelling and gentle gags combine for a memorable reflection on the importance of speaking up for what you believe in. Workman is the winner of a fair few awards (best comedy at…

Daniel Sloss discusses comics, critics and cookery

22 Aug 2012

The Fife comedian is a dab hand at cooking 'chicken thing' with rice

First record you ever bought Sadly I think it was Nickelback. I’ve never really been into music. This is probably why. Last extravagant purchase you made I bought a lifesize, fibreglass replica of a velociraptor. He’s 9 foot long and lives in my…

Kumail Nanjiani

22 Aug 20124 stars

Accomplished stand-up debut from the Pakistani-American comic

Kumail Nanjiani is a big fan of horror films. But as a natural beta male, he can’t quite cope with the feelings of terror they inspire in him and much of his life is spent in a state of fear. When he talks of being unable to visit the toilet during the…

Late Night Gimp Fight

22 Aug 20121 star

Risible, regrettable and rotten sketch comedy

Where to begin? Firstly, perhaps the lads behind Late Night Gimp Fight deserve some praise for sheer audacity. Not sure who thought they would regularly cram people into a venue the size of Pleasance Forth but it’s barely half-full on a night when not…

Sarah Kendall - Get Up, Stand-Up

22 Aug 20123 stars

Anticipated comeback show is good rather than glorious

When Sarah Kendall became the first woman in what felt like an entire generation to receive a solo Perrier nomination in 2004, her future glory seemed assured. But after one further Fringe stand-up show, a theatrical piece about a college initiation and…

back to top

Erich McElroy: The Brit Identity

22 Aug 20123 stars

A permanent cultural exchange with laughs

Whenever a comedian brings a show to the Fringe with any kind of social or political bent, the evolving nature of world events can often turn around to bite them in a soft fleshy place. In 2005, Andrew Maxwell was compelled to rewrite swathes of…

Neil Delamere - DelaMere Mortal

22 Aug 20123 stars

Safe but solid hour of craic

With such an easy-going manner and propensity for chatty audience banter, it helps if Neil Delamere can scoop out an interesting front-row character or two. And on this occasion, he uncovers a children’s author and the son of a notable ITV newsreader in…

Josie Long - Romance and Adventure

22 Aug 20123 stars

New found cynicism provides counterpoint to bubbliness and irrepressible daft voices

Josie Long has turned 30, and it’s changed her – if her last show was full of wide-eyed idealism and exhortations to activism, she’s now become fully acquainted with disillusionment. And not just the kind when everything’s wrong and you don’t know what…

Denise Scott - Regrets

22 Aug 20123 stars

Charm offensive from veteran debutant

One of the least likely comedy debuts this Fringe comes from Denise Scott, a jovial fiftysomething Australian who just so happens to be ‘incredibly famous’ back home. As she retells in one of several stories about her regrets, that fame was nearly…

Wil Hodgson: Kidnapped by Catwoman

22 Aug 20123 stars

A personal history of sexual turn ons

With The Dark Knight Rises ruling the box office this summer, Wil Hodgson has chosen a timely crush for the title of his new confessional comedy show on kinks, turn-ons and fantasies. As it turns out, he’s more interested in the 60s Adam West-era feline…

back to top

The Great Puppet Horn

22 Aug 20122 stars

Shadow puppetry show that leaves the comedy in another room

The Great Puppet Horn showed a devilish side recently by using their vast shadow puppet skills to project an image of Stewart Lee onto Edinburgh Castle. It was not an act of idolatry towards the agitprop comic, but the Horn guys were expressing their…

Rick Shapiro - Rebirth

22 Aug 20122 stars

The tragedy of Shapiro’s story means there is little to laugh at

It has always been strange to witness the tragedy at the heart of successful comedy. Voyeurism, schadenfreude, even embarrassment are tools of the audience when watching comics bear their soul for laughs. With Rick Shapiro however, there really is…

Gravity Boots

22 Aug 20121 star

Crashing down to earth with a massive bump

Making surreal humour work is probably the hardest trick to pull off in the comedy arena. Nail it and you will go a very long way; mess up and you just make a complete tit of yourself. Adelaide absurdists Gravity Boots do their best to be as weird as…

Xavier Toby - Binge Thinking

22 Aug 20122 stars

Comedy addressing big ideas let down by whistle-stop rhetoric and poor material

Toby relates the tale of a dinner party with three old male friends held after he returned from travelling. In that time they've all got married and Toby is unimpressed with how they've changed and with their choices in wives. For a while it's seventies…

The Silky Pair

22 Aug 20122 stars

A few sketches hit the mark, but feels cobbled together

Female duo The Silky Pair sells sketches and songs from their comedy shop. Punters have the chance to buy complete routines including outfits and hand gestures. It's a conceptual comedy cliché that's as old as The Two Ronnies but that doesn't mean it…